Volkswagen scandal

Les PK Ranger

4x4 Earth Contributer
..
Didn't see any thread about this here as yet, apologies if it's already been started . . .

Has only really broken in the mainstream media, regarding VWs putting in a 'cheat code' in the software to make diesel emissions look good, but only during emissions testing, other wise they shoot up to 20 - 30 times the allowable limits under normal driving !!

The who, what and why of Volkswagen’s diesel scandal

This is going to cost them many 10's of billions, hopefully not the end of the company, but they shouldn't have done this, that's for sure.
 

Aaron Schubert

Moderator
Haven't seen a thread about it here yet either. Read this yesterday; its a pretty major event.

Unbelievable that they got away with it for so long!

Aaron
 

Towie

Moderator
I did see some press on it and quotes of $2B plus were thrown around and with good reason too i think..
 

Les PK Ranger

4x4 Earth Contributer
I did see some press on it and quotes of $2B plus were thrown around and with good reason too i think..

In the article above, it cites US fines alone could be $25 billion, rectification work $10 bil, total could come in at $70 + billion !!

its a pretty major event.

Yeah for sure, it could well be the biggest ever scandal of the motoring industry, can't think of anything as big, maybe the Ford Pinto fire fiasco, or the GM faulty ignition incidents, but this is going to dwaft them cost wise.
 

mac_man_luke

Well-Known Member
I bet they are not the only ones, just the ones caught doing it.

Be interesting to see what the rectification work would be, if its just a software update i don't reckon id want it done as its going to cost power/economy/drivability.
 

Les PK Ranger

4x4 Earth Contributer
I bet they are not the only ones, just the ones caught doing it.

Be interesting to see what the rectification work would be, if its just a software update i don't reckon id want it done as its going to cost power/economy/drivability.

Looks like the UK is going to re-run emissions test on all diesel vehicles http://www.bbc.com/news/business-34352548

Rectification is most likely going to have to be remove dodgy cheat software, and probably bring emissions into line with what is permitted in various markets.
$$$ and lots of them.
Yes Luke, economy might be the big loser here.

I've always through how do some of these vehicle makers get diesels down to 5lt/100 or so, when the real world of some makes is up over 10lt/100, and yeah I know the heavier 4wds are going to always use more, but just thinking it could be all relevant.
 

Chatty

Well-Known Member
Yeah, but, credit where credit is due - full marks for being smart enough to program the vehicle to know when it was doing an emissions test and when it was just being driven on the road. :p
 

Les PK Ranger

4x4 Earth Contributer
Pretty sneaky yeah, and good German technology !
I wanna know why it didn't pick up on the Uni tests with all the stuff hooked up ??
 

chris_stoffa

4x4 Earth Contributer
They have admitted guilt , mea culpa, they will be fined, they will appeal, that will be confirmed/ reduced / increased and they will appeal.

They will be working on a legal solution , looking to send the US arm in Chapter 11 bankruptcy, and a workaround and if that doesnt work, they will appeal

Then they will still take it to the highest court in the land and appeal again ..................... and ultimately somebody , except Joe Citizen , will walk away much richer.
 

rogerazz

4x4 Earth Contributer
Something to think about.
I drove cars with leaded petrol, I repeat leaded petrol.:eek: So did everyone else in Australia. Guess what, still here.:D
What do catalytic converters, EGR valves, etc:eek:. do and why do we tamper with them????????? Hmmmmmm. Uh Oh, might have to dob youse all in to emission control.:rolleyes:
Emission control people many years ago took my old valiant wagon for testing. My missus got to drive a new Camry while the car was away.:D
Results I got back proved that after proper servicing, replacement of new plugs, points, leads, etc.etc. and a good tune up reduced the emissions back to factory standards.
No new cars today spew the sh't our cars spewed yesterday. Just drive a classic and smell what comes out the exhaust.:eek:
Funny thing about news report on the V Dubs. They said don't stand behind vehicle while it is running. Switch it off. Ha. Ha, Ha.
 

tankbloke

4x4 Earth Contributer
vw-test-jpg.98637
 

Chatty

Well-Known Member
Pretty sneaky yeah, and good German technology !
I wanna know why it didn't pick up on the Uni tests with all the stuff hooked up ??
I believe that it wasn't sensing the equipment - it was sensing the testing regime - meaning the testing sequence. The test sequence is prescribed as something like, "Wheels straight ahead, accelerate to X km/h, hold that speed for Y minutes... at an ambient temperature of Z degrees and an air pressure of R kPa" and so on. I understand that if the computer "saw" the conditions prescribed in the test sequence, it switched itself to "pass the test" mode.
 

Chatty

Well-Known Member
Something to think about.
I drove cars with leaded petrol, I repeat leaded petrol.:eek: So did everyone else in Australia. Guess what, still here.:D
Yeah, but look at what it did to you!

Oh, I've just remembered another thread about legal stuff. I fully withdraw the above comment and reiterate that I did not mean to impune the character, appearance or mental capacity of Rogerazz and that Rogerazz is, to the best of my knowledge a reasonably normal person. Of course, I don't have much knowledge :D
 

smitty_r51

Well-Known Member
I believe that it wasn't sensing the equipment - it was sensing the testing regime - meaning the testing sequence. The test sequence is prescribed as something like, "Wheels straight ahead, accelerate to X km/h, hold that speed for Y minutes... at an ambient temperature of Z degrees and an air pressure of R kPa" and so on. I understand that if the computer "saw" the conditions prescribed in the test sequence, it switched itself to "pass the test" mode.
They also get to disable things like traction control and other "tools" that are made for real life situations and not a lab test... They just turned off extra.

Makes you think that if the manufacturer's (and Volkswagen are just the ones who have been caught) are trying to work around all the emissions crap what it actually achieves... Surely it causes more environmental damage to have a car that runs sun optimally in terms of fuel economy and longevity than the emmisions stuff is attempting to resolve anyway?
 

rogerazz

4x4 Earth Contributer
Yeah, but look at what it did to you!

Oh, I've just remembered another thread about legal stuff. I fully withdraw the above comment and reiterate that I did not mean to impune the character, appearance or mental capacity of Rogerazz and that Rogerazz is, to the best of my knowledge a reasonably normal person. Of course, I don't have much knowledge :D
G'day. ( aussie slang) for goot morning.
I represent my client Rogerazz.
I refer to clause 1123456. para. 456789. of the Acme legal definitions of putting sh*t on peoples, as in humans.
On behalf of this idiot ( sorry , client) I demand that you remove all reference to your comments and please if you would be of the person to send me $1,000,000,00 Aud. to my suppository account care off the Acme wide world of Supremacy account. No 12345678910 c/o the Island of a very hot place. It would be pleasing of my client , just please if you being sending your detalis to this connection ( sorry link).
roger azz@ acme you beaut soolictiors,.com.ag.
Thanking you in anticipation , I remain your legal servant.
Please send me some money.
 

Les PK Ranger

4x4 Earth Contributer
Surely it causes more environmental damage to have a car that runs sun optimally in terms of fuel economy and longevity than the emmisions stuff is attempting to resolve anyway?

Exactly my thoughts mate.
EGR is great to reduce NO output in CRD engines and when they leave the factory and for a time they do this.
But when the intake system gets gummed up and the engine starts becoming uneconomical, burning much more fuel, pouring out more diesel carcinogenic particulates, what's the bloody point then ?
Not to mention failures of EGR coolers, which leads to $$$ worth of new parts needed, all with a manufacturing cost to the environment, not to mention the wallet.
 

Albynsw

Well-Known Member
Yep it is all about ticking a compliance box so that the product can be put up for sale
Nothing to do with big picture long term effects, reliability or longevity

Same goes for a lot of energy efficient items we fit in houses
Spent lots of $$$ chasing a saving that will never recoup the extra outlay
 

Outrage

4x4 Earth Contributer
I recall back from an auto engineering cause in uni, there was a similar thing done in the past (can't remember which make). When the bonnet was down, the vehicle would be in 'normal' operating mode.

Emissions tests were done with the bonnet up. When the bonnet was up, it switched to 'emissions' mode in order to pass.
 
Top