To Solder or Crimp Connections

Swaggie

Moderator
OK read some debates on this subject on a number of different forums, was starting to lean towards crimping when I spoke to an auto electrician a few weeks back, he said always solder as the wire shrinks...:eek:


What are your thoughts on this subject.....
 
Last edited:

joebog

New Member
ALL military stuff these days is crimped !!! as are all aircraft looms.
I solder :D I always have. BUT solderimng "softens ( anneals) " the copper where you solder it, and it will break 10 times ?? ( read MUCH ) faster than crimped.
Yep wire shrinks and the crimp comes off when you use a $2 crimp tool from Dick Smith!!
A REAL crimp tool is coupla hundred dollars. Go figure!!

Joe
 

joebog

New Member
Bit the same as soldering circuit boards !!!
I employed 30 girls at one stage hand soldering PCB,s
every now and then they missed a joint!!! warranty loss of profit blah blah.
THEN I did wave soldering ( a big bath that the curcuit board is held JUST above a big pool of melted liquid solder) THere is a "paddle" at one end that plunges into the melted solder. ALL joints on the curcuit board " get a hit" less failures !!!

PROBLEM is all the parts get a decent "frying" before they are even used, MOSTLY they survive. Wave soldering uses special solder that "crystalizes) and causes WAY more dry joints than hand soldering. Hand soldering ( good operator) doesnt overheat parts or PCB,s

Yeah I know its off topic, its just another old versus new argument!!
like synthetic versus mineral oil
 

mac_man_luke

Well-Known Member
I solder everything i can except large wires e.g. winch cables. where a good crimp is easier.

Crimping can be done extremely well but needs good fittings and good tools e.g. hex crimp instead of just squashing the terminal.
 

peterfermtech

Well-Known Member
If I'm joining wires I will solder, otherwise crimp. The readily available automotive crimps that come in blister packs come in different sizes. Make sure you have correct size for your wire and always give the wire a good tug to make sure your crimp has taken hold.

regards
 

bally

Banned
best connection and a connection that wont need to be disconnected again will be soldered, if its a connection thats likely to be disconnected again its crimped.....
 

cookie64

4x4 Earth Contributer
Guys what I do is strip the wire, tin the top end, sleeve the wire, crimp using a proper ratchet loaded Hex Crimper, then solder the tip to the top of the crimp, pop the heatshrink over the lot and shrink it down - this assists with the mechanical stress of the join.

cheers
 

patrolgu4

Active Member
Crimping wires is superior to soldering for mechanical stresses however proper crimping method and tools need to be used. Tinning the copper and than crimp it is the worst thing to do.
Leave the soldering for circuit boards.

Cheers
 
Last edited:

Swaggie

Moderator
Guys what I do is strip the wire, tin the top end, sleeve the wire, crimp using a proper ratchet loaded Hex Crimper, then solder the tip to the top of the crimp, pop the heatshrink over the lot and shrink it down - this assists with the mechanical stress of the join.

cheers

Hoya Bud

What you mean by a sleaving ????...A step by step guide with pictures would be brilliant..:);)
 

boobook

Well-Known Member
Commercial production crimping machines are very different to hand tools. They are set to particular pressures and timing. You simply can not compare the type of crimp used for planes and vehicle manufacture with post production hand tool work. Also it is MUUUUUUUUUCH cheaper to crimp for production. That's why most auto elecs like them too. Quick and cheap.

However the average crimp with even a good crimping tool is no where near as resilient. Any crimping tool that isn't a double crimp, and costs less that than about $60 belongs in the bin.

Soldering, done properly is a lot better and more reliable, it forms a chemical alloy bond as opposed to a pressure fit, eliminating corrosion intrusion. However a poor solder joint is as bad as using a cheap crimping tool, and both joins are bound to fail.

For home use get a good, appropriately sized soldering iron and learn to use it. The joints will outlast your crimping by years. Applying solder to the join, not the iron is the first rule.
 
Last edited:

PJR NSW

Banned
If I'm joining wires I will solder, otherwise crimp. The readily available automotive crimps that come in blister packs come in different sizes. Make sure you have correct size for your wire and always give the wire a good tug to make sure your crimp has taken hold.

regards

Same same.

With larger wires I may solder as well as crimp.

Phil
 

cookie64

4x4 Earth Contributer
Crimping wires is superior to soldering for mechanical stresses however proper crimping method and tools need to be used. Tinning the copper and than crimp it is the worst thing to do.
Leave the soldering for circuit boards.

Cheers

Note I said to tin the tip of the wire and not the whole wire, this keeps the strands together and negates overheating the insulation when soldering to the crimp in the last stage

Soldering does provide a superior electrical connection not subjected to corrosion within the crimp body but it can make the copper stiff if soldered all the way through this is where the heatshrink comes in to play as it provides electrical insulation and mechanical stability.

cheers
 

patrolgu4

Active Member
I'll keep it simple, nearly every electrical failure I have to fix on heavy vehicles is due to aftermarket cluey autoleky fitting something and soldering and guess what solder joint failed!

I'm tired of these clown let me put frankly when I have to go out in the middle of the night when "B Double" is stranded on the side of the road with electrical failure because some toser who knows better decided to solder something on to trucks electrical system.

I don't use $10 toy crimping pliers nor I'm advocating such. I use professional $200 + crimping pliers and I had no fail yet! Heck I even use "el cheapo" ones ($60) and still have no fail.

Correct soldering requires skill to do properly, anyone can master to squeeze pliers.

Cheers
 

joebog

New Member
solder/crimp

I'll keep it simple, nearly every electrical failure I have to fix on heavy vehicles is due to aftermarket cluey autoleky fitting something and soldering and guess what solder joint failed!

I'm tired of these clown let me put frankly when I have to go out in the middle of the night when "B Double" is stranded on the side of the road with electrical failure because some toser who knows better decided to solder something on to trucks electrical system.

I don't use $10 toy crimping pliers nor I'm advocating such. I use professional $200 + crimping pliers and I had no fail yet! Heck I even use "el cheapo" ones ($60) and still have no fail.

Correct soldering requires skill to do properly, anyone can master to squeeze pliers.

Cheers


This bloke has done the hard yards NOTE WELL decent crimping tool is $200!!!

so is a half decent soldering iron !!!! solder is also pretty different !!!
as is flux !! Killed spirits AKA Bakers fluid is OUT for ANY electrical work!!!
Old fashioned ( if ya even find it today ) soft Rosin ( yep pine tree say !!! ) in a tin I havent seen for years. Rosin cored solder ( VERY often MISPELLED Resin cored solder) comes in at least 2 easy to get varieties that I know of
50/50, and 60/40
The numbers mean the amount of tin and lead used in the alloy.
50/50 is best for auto use. 60/40 is for circuit boards.
50/50 is harder to use because it melts at a much higher temperature to 60/40.
60/40 has more tin (60% ) so it flows easier and covers dry joints MUCH more successfully than 50/50
DECENT auto sparkeys are like gold hens teeth, and I DONT mean any disrespect !!! ANY auto sparky that has even ONE SINGLE Scotch lock or its even NASTIER chinese equivelent has learnt NOTHING at all, and any repairs or accessory fitting WILL FAIL Ill put bloody money on it.
There are times when you need soldering, AND there are times to use crimps
a " decent auto sparky will ( or should ) explain the difference and quote accordingly.

This is maybe off topic, but its been my life since about age 8! and I take GREAT pride in all things electrical, when I make it.
NO SUCH THING as half arsed electrical!!!
with high voltage it will kill you !!!
with low voltage it can leave you stranded
BAD auto electrical work can require a complete new loom ( extreme case )
THEN you need somebody that can REPLACE the loom where the factory intended it.
NOT draped over your extractors !!!

Joe
 

cookie64

4x4 Earth Contributer
Correct soldering requires skill to do properly, anyone can master to squeeze pliers.
Cheers

Totally agree, I have seen someone advocating soldering with a blowtorch - WTF

I used to work on military gear and our soldering was always inspected, indeed we were only allowed to use particular soldering equipment / stations - there is a very clear way of achieving a good joint but too many people make a dogs breakfast of it for sure.

cheers
 

Lays4B

Member
There's pros and cons to both techniques. I prefer soldering because it's less bulky and once it's heat shrunk and tied in place there is little chance of any stress on the join. With soldering you need to know what your doing, there are ways of splicing wires which best suits soldering and there are also correct soldering techniques.

With crimping you need good crimpers suited to the connector type (I have about 5 different crimpers) and connectors are more expensive in the long run over solder. You can get some cheap and nasty crimp connectors out there too. I always carry some connectors in my traveling toolbox in case a quick connection is required.

Solder Pros:
Neat and less bulky
Cheaper when doing lots of connections

Solder Cons:
Takes longer
Need to know what you're doing with splicing and soldering
Need an energy source

Crimping Pros:
Quicker
Easier
Doesn't require an energy source

Crimping Cons:
Bulkier and not as neat
More expensive
Need decent connectors

I'm a sparky and I've seen some terrible solder joins and some terrible crimp connections. Both done properly will give you a good connection and both done wrong will give you a bad connection, simple as that.
 

drivesafe

Active Member
I both manufacture dual battery cable looms and supply DIY kit.

99% of my connections are done by crimping, because it’s quicker when you have the correct tools and know how to use them.

But for my DIY kits, unless the DIYer has access to the correct tools, I recommend the DIYer solder the large cable terminals in place for one simple reason, if you crimp and get it wrong, you throw the terminal away and get a new one, which is all good and well if you have easy access to more terminals.

This can be a major problem, accessing new terminals, if you live somewhere remote, as many of my customer do.

Whereas, if you stuff up a solder joint or connection, simply heat it up remove the cable and start again.

For novices, I have found that soldering is by far the best way to go and to help, I even supply a length of the correct resin core solder.

BTW, Hi joebog and the yanks call it rosin while the English call it resin. Both words are correct.
 

joebog

New Member
Rosin/Resin

Bet ya you have that around the wrong way !!!!

hers an add for English made Ersin multicore solder
maybe you confused it with resin cored soder ?? :D

Joe
 

Attachments

  • rosin-resin.jpeg
    rosin-resin.jpeg
    276.5 KB · Views: 214

boobook

Well-Known Member
SNIP

Rosin cored solder ( VERY often MISPELLED Resin cored solder)

SNIP

Joe


Not so.

There are many types of flux for soldering.

Rosin is a naturally occurring substance often used in the old days or for clean environments. It is easy to clean but not a very strong as a flux.

Resin flux is synthetic and may contain Rosin. It is generally used for exposed or high reliability joints. It is by far the most common type used in electronics / electrical.

People use these interchangeably which is wrong.

BTW you misspelled "Misspelled". ;)
 
Top