Newbie Q

SIX36

New Member
Being new to 4WD's been racing road bikes for years so any bike Q's send them on...lol

With talk on the new Patrol and it now being independent F&R suspension, was the GU a solid axle?

Can someone explain the pros & cons between a solid axle & independant suspension?
 

03hilux

4x4 Earth Contributer
Yes the GU was a solid axle front and rear.
As for the pro's and cons; A solid axle when flexed, both wheels are able to search for traction because the wheel that is extended downward is having pressure applied by the opposite wheel being compressed. sort of like a lever. With independant, the wheels lift alot easier because suspension travel is limited. Each corner of the car ( wheel and suspension) work as the name suggest, independant, of each other.
A solid axle vehicle is also alot cheaper and easier to lift, and can generally be lifted more than a couple of inches without having to mortage the house.

Hope this all makes sense. If someone else can explain it better, go for it.
 

Outrage

4x4 Earth Contributer
Independent suspension is about road handling and comfort, it's why sedans and the like have been using it for a long time. For the very same reason mentioned before, in a solid axle vehicle, if on one hits a pot hole, the other wheel feels it too as left and right are connected, giving a larger jolt to the driver and occupants. Independent, as only one wheel is affected, there is less jolt/vibration as only one wheel feels the pot hole.

4wd's have used solid axle because it is simpler/cheaper and stronger (less weak points), and as mentioned, has more wheel travel and easier to modify. But as these cars have become more popular with tourers and people just wanting a big vehicle, comfort has become a bigger market for large 4wds compared to 'bush/track capability'.

In that sense you can't blame a manufacturer for going down that path, their ultimate goal is the $ sign.

So in short:

Solid/Live axle = more capable

Independent (IFS) = road handling & comfort
 
Top