Ebay winch's first recovery

Fourex

Member
I tried out my new winch today, a cheapie off Ebay. Here's a link to the add http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/13000LBS...284253?hash=item56685f9ddd:g:1CoAAOSwPv9XMFqX
I have owned 2 winches previously, the old hand powered 2 tonne type, but I'm a bit over them so thought that it was time to buy a luxury electric model. There is a 12 month warranty offered, but I didn't bother reading the fine print so I'm not sure how extensive it is.
I bribed my son into fitting the winch for me by offering to buy him one too. (ya gotta love a good tax return)
The roobar that came with my fourby doesn't have a manufacturers sticker on it so I don't know which brand it is, and I wasn't impressed by the lightweight design,(although it did come with the winch bolt pattern holes and a fairlead slot already cut into it) so he braced it with 10mm plate and a few well placed gussets, which probably added on about 10-15 kilo's on top of the 30 something kilo's of the winch. The extra combined weight over the front end of the car makes for a smoother ride so that's a bonus!
The only problem we found with the kit was the size of the small allen head bolt that is supposed to hold the rope onto the side of the winch drum, it was too short to go through the rope's metal crimp properly, and would have been holding by 2 threads at the most, so he replaced it with a proper sized bolt and then carefully ground most of the head off it so that it wouldn't catch or tear the rope.
The first time I used it I pulled out a bogged 4wd tractor from a local paddock, it did the job easily enough, although I had to anchor my vehicle with another to stop mine sliding forward even though I had my foot on the brake, so there was a decent load to pull.
The first 30-45 seconds of winching nearly took my virtually brand new 700cca battery down to 11 volts, and that was with the motor idling at 1000 revs, the tractors wheels had dug into the ground about half a metre, but once it was out of the ruts the winch motor sped up some. I decided to idle the engine higher to get more charge going to the battery, so I took the revs up to 1600 which worked a lot better and gave the winch more go juice. The rope didn't wind onto the winch drum very evenly, so after we had winched the tractor 20 metres we removed an extension strap from the line, and spooled out the line and started with about 7 turns of rope on the drum, there's only so much room behind the roo bar and I didn't want to damage the rope by letting it rub on anything.
Once the tractor got onto some higher ground and actually got some traction, we unhooked the winch cable and wound it back in under slight tension, and then after another 10 minutes of fast idling and a 2 minute drive home, the battery was showing 13 volts. I put a small battery charger on it and the battery was only taking 1-2 amps, so was virtually recharged.(which was surprising since the alternator is only a 40 amp stocky) Winch run time was a good 10 minutes all up, but there was a 5 minute break when the extension strap was removed. I put my hand onto the winch motor during this break and it was warm, but not hot. I'm pretty happy with it so far, I have no idea how long it will last, but it has paid for itself already, as getting a tow/winch truck out to my location doesn't leave much change from $500. Shit, I've written a small novel lol, I'll updatethis post when I finally break it!
Here's some Iphone video
 
Last edited:

typhoeus

Well-Known Member
Hey, did you check the bearings/repack with grease etc before install, or just fit it up? I hear they always need a bit more grease than what the factory uses.
 

Swaggie

Moderator
When winching I use the 30 second on and 30 seconds off, (roughly, if the batt needs more time and revs, give it time to recover a bit, although duel batts with link option is a lot better) you'll strip batteries otherwise... Also if a winch is struggling use a double line pull..

Cheers
 

Fourex

Member
I looked at that one but there was no way I was paying $170 for postage . I bought this one and the solenoid box has a solid resin filled solenoid and seals on motor and gearbox , already had the right grease and enough of it . has 30 mtr rope . http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/161404091004?_trksid=p2060353.m2749.l2649&ssPageName=STRK:MEBIDX:IT
That winch looks like a good buy too, I got a discount on the postage because I bought 2 winches, for $851. posted, which is $425 each. Postage for one winch was only going to be $39. because I'm only an hour and a bit out of Melbourne which is where the sellers warehouse is located.
 

Fourex

Member
When winching I use the 30 second on and 30 seconds off, (roughly, if the batt needs more time and revs, give it time to recover a bit, although duel batts with link option is a lot better) you'll strip batteries otherwise... Also if a winch is struggling use a double line pull..

Cheers
I could have done the 30 seconds on/off pull, (and/or a double line pull) but I really wanted to test out the winch to see how well it was made and see how capable it was. The tractor weighs 6 tonnes, and was dug in a bit too, and the pull was up a slight incline, so the winch had to work hard for the first 30 or so seconds, then the load decreased somewhat. I'm currently mulling over possible locations for a second battery, I might wait and see just how often the winch gets used as I already have added an extra 50ish kilo's of weight to the vehicle between the winch and 10 mil plating, and an extra battery will take that weight up to around 80 kilo's, add in the roobar's weight and I'm up to over 100 kg's over standard, but then all that weight makes for a smoother ride on the road so maybe it's not such a negative. Idling the engine at 1600 revs helped keep the battery from draining too much, so I'll definitely be doing that during any future recoveries.
 

GaryM

Well-Known Member
Im pretty sure one reason to swap grease from Chinese winches is some have been found to contain swarf from the production process. I got a Runva but it will be repacked with water resistant grease before I install it. I have a cartridge of the Castrol blue stuff whatever that is. IIRC its suitable for wheel bearings, high pressure and doesnt contain clay.
 

Tink

Well-Known Member
Most alternators only start producing their maximum output over 1500 engine rpm so that would explain why your winch gained that little extra power.
Tink
 

muc the truck

Well-Known Member
Im pretty sure one reason to swap grease from Chinese winches is some have been found to contain swarf from the production process. I got a Runva but it will be repacked with water resistant grease before I install it. I have a cartridge of the Castrol blue stuff whatever that is. IIRC its suitable for wheel bearings, high pressure and doesnt contain clay.
Actually in NT I had a winch pulled down in a workshop over night and the next Morning cockroaches were eating the grease so it must have been fat or canola based .
 

Fourex

Member
Im pretty sure one reason to swap grease from Chinese winches is some have been found to contain swarf from the production process. I got a Runva but it will be repacked with water resistant grease before I install it. I have a cartridge of the Castrol blue stuff whatever that is. IIRC its suitable for wheel bearings, high pressure and doesnt contain clay.
I'm guessing that, like a cars gearbox, the winch gearbox will lose some metal to the lubricant during the first few hours of operation, a "running in" period. I might pull it out in a few months and give it a service.
 
D

Deleted member 69390

Guest
Ebay (chinese) winches should have the grease replaced with a decent product and all the nuts and bolts removed and re torqued with loctite - also any sealing surfaces should should have some sealant put on them.
 

GaryM

Well-Known Member
Actually in NT I had a winch pulled down in a workshop over night and the next Morning cockroaches were eating the grease so it must have been fat or canola based .
I emailed Runva in Aus asked what grease was right for them, they said anything is fine just nothing too thick. I asked an oil distributor on the Sunny Coast (at Coolum now) for a waterproof, high temp, high pressure grease and told what I was using it in. I mentioned it had rubber seals and one of its selling points was it was watertight and I didnt want to compromise the seals. He handed me a cartridge of the Castrol grease. Many rubber greases are castor oil based, and often rubber grease is used where theres rubber. But I think it lacked one of the properties I was chasing. Other greases and oils can start to make rubber go goey, like old rubber boots on ball joints. Yet others are perfect 30 years on.

I'm guessing that, like a cars gearbox, the winch gearbox will lose some metal to the lubricant during the first few hours of operation, a "running in" period. I might pull it out in a few months and give it a service.
Widely touted via experience that Chinese made winches often have swarf, not bits off the gears etc. I also wouldnt be happy if running in the winch it sheared metal from itself. As Ive read, from avarious people the winch would have been fine if it wasnt for the swarf they never found until too late. Ive not found any swarf in mine and Ive had it apart, havent removed the red grease yet though, but it is one of the better Chinese winches. Ill still change it before I install, better safe than sorry and at least then i know its got what we in Aus would consider a decent grease instead of an unknown.Like I said, I asked Runva, couldnt get a specific answer on the grease type, let alone brand.

They arent hard to pull down anyway and its good to see and know how they work, and grease is not expensive. Seems like the wiser otpion to me. I paid nearly $700 for it, $9 for a cartridge of grease I will use on other things seems like cheap insurance, and an enjoyable evening.
 
Last edited:

muc the truck

Well-Known Member
I emailed Runva in Aus asked what grease was right for them, they said anything is fine just nothing too thick. I asked an oil distributor on the Sunny Coast (at Coolum now) for a waterproof, high temp, high pressure grease and told what I was using it in. I mentioned it had rubber seals and one of its selling points was it was watertight and I didnt want to compromise the seals. He handed me a cartridge of the Castrol grease. Many rubber greases are castor oil based, and often rubber grease is used where theres rubber. But I think it lacked one of the properties I was chasing. Other greases and oils can start to make rubber go goey, like old rubber boots on ball joints. Yet others are perfect 30 years on.


Widely touted via experience that Chinese made winches often have swarf, not bits off the gears etc. I also wouldnt be happy if running in the winch it sheared metal from itself. As Ive read, from avarious people the winch would have been fine if it wasnt for the swarf they never found until too late. Ive not found any swarf in mine and Ive had it apart, havent removed the red grease yet though, but it is one of the better Chinese winches. Ill still change it before I install, better safe than sorry and at least then i know its got what we in Aus would consider a decent grease instead of an unknown.Like I said, I asked Runva, couldnt get a specific answer on the grease type, let alone brand.

They arent hard to pull down anyway and its good to see and know how they work, and grease is not expensive. Seems like the wiser otpion to me. I paid nearly $700 for it, $9 for a cartridge of grease I will use on other things seems like cheap insurance, and an enjoyable evening.
I think the assertion you made about rubber balljoints boots is way off . The absolute crap they substitute and call rubber is the cause the boots fail not the grease you fill them with . For example If you own a old Holden or ford from the 70s the only balljoints boots you can buy now that last are Red polly. Because all the aftermarket so called replacement ome stuff is just rubbish. The tie rods are fine but not the boots.
 

Fourex

Member
Widely touted via experience that Chinese made winches often have swarf, not bits off the gears etc. I also wouldnt be happy if running in the winch it sheared metal from itself. As Ive read, from avarious people the winch would have been fine if it wasnt for the swarf they never found until too late. Ive not found any swarf in mine and Ive had it apart, havent removed the red grease yet though, but it is one of the better Chinese winches. Ill still change it before I install, better safe than sorry and at least then i know its got what we in Aus would consider a decent grease instead of an unknown.Like I said, I asked Runva, couldnt get a specific answer on the grease type, let alone brand.

They arent hard to pull down anyway and its good to see and know how they work, and grease is not expensive. Seems like the wiser otpion to me. I paid nearly $700 for it, $9 for a cartridge of grease I will use on other things seems like cheap insurance, and an enjoyable evening.
The winch was ordered Monday evening, delivered on thursday morning, mounted Friday morning, and pulled a tractor out of a boggy paddock Sat morning, saving a $500. tow company bill. It's already paid for itself, and it's running well. If I procrastinated and got the right grease, pulled it to bits and repacked it, loctited the bolts, purchased some extension power cords to extend the control box to a safe location out of harms way, the winch would still be sitting on the bench along with another half a dozen "must do's" Sometimes it's better to just do it I think.
 

GaryM

Well-Known Member
I think the assertion you made about rubber balljoints boots is way off . The absolute crap they substitute and call rubber is the cause the boots fail not the grease you fill them with . For example If you own a old Holden or ford from the 70s the only balljoints boots you can buy now that last are Red polly. Because all the aftermarket so called replacement ome stuff is just rubbish. The tie rods are fine but not the boots.
Yeah modern stuff is mostly garbage. But the ones in my 78 XC are still perfect. Yet Ive had Ford factory balljoints 20 years ago perished from the wrong grease. In know they were factory as I had to chisel the rivets. Te rod ends are fine as they are usually non greaseable, which supports the assertion. Not that thats uncommon to modern balljoints either now. But tie rod ends have been nippleless for yonks.
 

GaryM

Well-Known Member
The winch was ordered Monday evening, delivered on thursday morning, mounted Friday morning, and pulled a tractor out of a boggy paddock Sat morning, saving a $500. tow company bill. It's already paid for itself, and it's running well. If I procrastinated and got the right grease, pulled it to bits and repacked it, loctited the bolts, purchased some extension power cords to extend the control box to a safe location out of harms way, the winch would still be sitting on the bench along with another half a dozen "must do's" Sometimes it's better to just do it I think.
Its an hours job. The grease is off the shelf, Marine as mentioned would be OK, and water proof. Im in no rush.

Just be aware, theres plenty of stories with pics a googles search away showing how moisture milks up the grease, and trashes the insides of the winch. Not water crossings, getting it hot by use, and moisture in the air.
 

Fourex

Member
I've already decided on a service, I'll probably follow Swaggies thread when I do eventually get around to it.
 

muc the truck

Well-Known Member
Yeah modern stuff is mostly garbage. But the ones in my 78 XC are still perfect. Yet Ive had Ford factory balljoints 20 years ago perished from the wrong grease. In know they were factory as I had to chisel the rivets. Te rod ends are fine as they are usually non greaseable, which supports the assertion. Not that thats uncommon to modern balljoints either now. But tie rod ends have been nippleless for yonks.
you can still buy grease nipple tie rods today . just have to ask for them .
 
Top